THE SEVENTH CHAIR

A year after that dinner, Marcus proposed to me on the very steps of the studio where we first met.

He had no diamond ring.

He gave me a simple silver band he had cast himself, engraved inside with a small phrase: “Pour celle qui voit ce que les autres ignorent” — For the one who sees what others overlook.

I cried, not because of the ring, but because for the first time in my life I felt truly, completely seen.

Telling my family wasn’t as easy as I’d hoped.

“Are you sure?” my mother asked over the phone, her disappointment unmistakable. “He still doesn’t have a stable job, does he?”

“He’s a painter, Mom. That is his job.”

“I’m not saying he has no talent. I’m saying he has no money, Camille. Those are two different things.”

The call ended in the same awkward silence as every other call between my mother and me over the years.

I decided to hold the wedding anyway, despite our tight budget.

We rented a small restaurant along a canal called Le Jardin des Lilas, capacity for forty-two guests, tucked away in an alley in the 10th arrondissement.

It was the loveliest place we could afford — an old stone courtyard, a wisteria arbor draped over the awning, and a worn piano the owner let us use free of charge.

I sent the invitations to my family in April, choosing the wedding date: the fifteenth of June, a Saturday.

Margaux called me the very next day after receiving hers.

“Camille, I need to tell you something.”

Her voice was so cheerful I assumed she was calling to congratulate me.

“Julien and I decided to hold Théo’s naming party — on the fifteenth of June too. What a coincidence, right?”

I was silent for a moment, trying to process what she’d just said.

“You… you do know that’s my wedding day, right?”

“Oh, I completely forgot!” Margaux laughed, a light little laugh, as if we were discussing the weather. “But you know, Théo’s party has been booked with Le Meurice for three months already, changing the date would be so difficult. And he’s the first grandchild, that matters a lot, you know.”

I hung up the phone, my hand still shaking.

I called my mother right after, hoping she would see the absurdity of it.

“Mom, Margaux is holding Théo’s party on my wedding day.”

“I know,” my mother replied, her voice unsettlingly calm. “That’s a matter for the grown-ups, Camille. Her first grandchild’s naming party matters a great deal. You understand, don’t you?”

“And what about my wedding, Mom?”

“You could still change the date. Your wedding doesn’t have as many guests as Margaux’s party, it’d be easier to move.”

That sentence — it’d be easier to move — cut through my chest like a blade.

Not because my mother chose Margaux.

But because she said it as though it were self-evident, beyond debate: my wedding was smaller, so it deserved to be sacrificed first.

That night I told Marcus, curled up on the studio floor amid half-finished paintings.

He said nothing for a long while, just sat beside me, his arm around my shoulders.

“We could still change the date,” he finally said, gently. “If it would bring your family together.”

“No,” I said, and for the first time in my life I felt something harden inside me. “If I change the date this once, I’ll be changing everything else for them for the rest of my life.”

Marcus looked at me for a long moment, then nodded.

“Then we keep the fifteenth of June.”

I didn’t know then that this small decision — keeping one date on a calendar — would become the first brick of everything that followed.

—