THE SEVENTH CHAIR
Three years after that first dinner, Marcus and I were still together, and the family dinners still followed a pattern I had come to know by heart.
One Friday evening in September, my mother invited everyone over to celebrate Julien closing a major shipping contract with a Dutch conglomerate.
The table was set more carefully than usual — white linen tablecloth, the crystal glasses reserved only for special occasions, a Bordeaux my father had been cellaring for years, waiting for “a worthy moment.”
Julien was poured wine in that crystal glass.
Marcus was poured wine in an ordinary glass tumbler, the kind my mother bought in sets of six from the supermarket.
I noticed the difference the moment I sat down, but said nothing, only watched quietly, wondering if I was simply too sensitive.
“So Julien’s company is doing business with all of Europe now?” my father asked, brimming with enthusiasm, leaning toward his son-in-law.
“That’s right, we just opened two new routes through the port of Rotterdam,” Julien answered, voice confident, sweeping his hand as if drawing a map of Europe in the air.
“Wonderful, wonderful,” my father nodded repeatedly. “That’s how a man builds a future for his family.”
That sentence landed on the table like a small stone, and I saw Marcus lower his head slightly, his hand tightening around his plain glass.
“And Marcus,” my mother turned, her tone shifting entirely, gentle but somehow inquiring, as if addressing a child. “Have you sold any paintings lately?”
“I sold two just last week, madam,” Marcus answered, trying to keep his voice steady. “To a client in Lyon.”
“Oh, how much?” Julien asked, his tone curious but laced with a hard-to-hide condescension.
“Four hundred fifty euros each,” Marcus said.
Julien let out a light laugh, trying to mask it by taking a sip of wine. “Huh. That’s about half a day’s wage for the lowest-paid employee at my company.”
No one at the table objected.
No one defended Marcus.
I opened my mouth to say something, but my mother quickly changed the subject, asking Margaux about decorating the nursery for her soon-to-arrive baby.
The whole table immediately buzzed back to life, as though Julien’s comment had never happened, as though the silence before it had never meant anything.
On the drive home, Marcus drove slowly through the dark streets, saying nothing for a long while.
“I’m sorry about that dinner,” I said, my hand resting on his thigh.
“You don’t need to apologize for your family,” he said, his voice not angry, just carrying a quiet exhaustion. “I just wish, even once, they could see that a painting’s worth isn’t measured by the number it sold for.”
I had no answer good enough for him that night.
I only knew to hold his hand tighter, and to promise myself that no matter how my family looked at Marcus, I would never let him feel alone in the story of our love.
—