The Man Who Sat Next to Me on the Red-Eye Was Wearing My Dead Husband’s Watch

Part 2: The Coffee Shop on Ferry Street

Marisol Vega was waiting for me at a coffee shop in Newark called Rook & Bean, a narrow place with exposed brick and too many plants. She stood up when I walked in. She was smaller than I had expected, maybe sixty, silver hair cropped short, reading glasses pushed up on her head.

She recognized me from the picture I had sent.

“Claire,” she said. “Thank you for coming.”

I sat down across from her. I had not slept. I had spent the entire flight beside a man who was, apparently, married to a woman who thought Daniel was her father. I had watched him deplane and walk toward baggage claim with the easy stride of a person going home to his life.

I had not followed him. I had not been able to move for a long time.

“I sat next to your son-in-law on the plane,” I said.

Marisol went very still.

“Ethan,” I said. “Sandy hair. Wearing Daniel’s watch. He told me his father-in-law’s name.”

She closed her eyes. When she opened them they were wet.

“Oh, honey,” she said. “That was not supposed to happen like that.”

“Nothing about this was supposed to happen,” I said. “Start talking.”

She wrapped both hands around her coffee cup. She did not drink from it. She looked at me like she was measuring how much I could hold.

“Daniel was married before you,” she said.

“No, he wasn’t.”

“He was.”

“I saw his divorce papers. He was married once, in his twenties, to a woman named Rebecca, for eighteen months. It ended in 1996.”

“He was also married to my daughter Anna,” Marisol said. “From 1999 to 2011. They had a daughter together. Her name is Sophie. She is twenty-four. She is Ethan’s wife.”

The coffee shop kept making its coffee shop sounds. Someone was steaming milk. A door chime rang.

“That’s not possible,” I said. “We met in 2010. We got married in 2013. He would have been, he was, married to someone else the whole time we were dating?”

“For part of it,” Marisol said. “Yes.”

“And he had a daughter.”

“He had a daughter.”

I put my hands flat on the table because I needed something solid.

“Why are you telling me this now,” I said, “and not fourteen months ago at his funeral, which I assume you did not attend.”

“I attended,” Marisol said quietly. “I sat in the back. You were in the front row with his mother. I did not want to make it worse.”

“Make it worse.”

“Sophie was there too. She sat next to me.”

I stared at her.

“Sophie was at my husband’s funeral.”

“Sophie was at her father’s funeral,” Marisol said. “That was how she understood it. That was how he had presented it to her, her whole life. Anna raised her mostly, but Daniel visited. Birthdays, some Christmases, the occasional weekend. He was, he was a distant father, but he was her father. She loved him.”

“He told me he was traveling for work,” I said. My voice sounded very far away. “He was gone one week a month. He said it was the regional accounts.”

“He was in New Jersey,” Marisol said. “With them.”

I thought about the eight years of IVF. I thought about the Panera parking lot. I thought about Daniel holding my hand across the console and saying, *We have each other. That’s enough. That has to be enough.*

He had a daughter. She was eleven years old the year we cried in that parking lot. She was learning to play the clarinet. She was losing her front teeth. She was somewhere in New Jersey being tucked in by a mother my husband had never divorced.

“The watch,” I said.

“Anna kept the watch after he died,” Marisol said. “It was one of the things he had left at her house years ago. When Sophie got engaged, Anna gave it to Ethan. It was supposed to be a gesture. Something of Sophie’s father, passed on.”

“He wasn’t dead when he left it at her house.”

“No.”

“He was cheating on me.”

“He was cheating on both of you,” Marisol said. “For twelve years.”

I laughed. It came out wrong, a hard flat sound.

“Why did you email me, Marisol? Why now? He’s dead. What’s the point?”

She reached into her bag and pulled out an envelope. Cream-colored, heavy paper, the kind lawyers use.

“Because Anna died three weeks ago,” she said. “Pancreatic cancer. It was very fast.”

She slid the envelope across the table.

“And because Sophie is my granddaughter, and she just found out her father was a bigamist, and she does not know what to do with any of it. She wanted me to reach out to you. She wanted you to know she exists. She was afraid if she reached out herself you would think she wanted something from you.”

“Does she?”

“No,” Marisol said. “She wants to know if you would be willing to meet her. That is all. She said if you say no, she understands, and she will never contact you again.”

I looked at the envelope. My name was on it in careful handwriting.

*Claire.*

Not Mrs. Whitaker. Not Daniel’s wife. Just Claire.

“How did she find out?” I asked. “About me.”

“She found the second marriage certificate in Anna’s papers, going through the house after the funeral. She Googled you. She saw the obituary you wrote. She read the part where you said he was the love of your life who never got to be a father.”

Marisol paused.

“She cried for two days,” she said. “She said she was sorry.”

“For what?”

“For existing,” Marisol said. “Her word, not mine.”

I picked up the envelope. I did not open it.

Outside the coffee shop window a woman was walking a small brown dog. The dog stopped to sniff a tree. The woman waited, patient, checking her phone. The most ordinary thing in the world.

“I need to think,” I said.

“Take as long as you need.”

I stood up. My legs did not feel entirely mine.

“Marisol,” I said. “Why are you being kind to me? I am the woman who took your daughter’s husband.”

She looked up at me. Her eyes were the same shape as her daughter’s, I realized. I had seen a picture of Anna in the funeral program Marisol had brought.

“You didn’t take anyone,” she said. “He took himself. He gave pieces of himself to different people and pretended each piece was the whole thing. You got cheated the same as she did. The only difference is she got a daughter out of it, and you got nothing.”

She paused.

“Sophie is not nothing, though. I want you to know that. Whatever you decide.”

—