My Sister-in-Law Told Everyone I Stole $12,000 From My Dying Mother, She Didn’t Know About the Bank Cameras

Part 3: What Mom Left in Bill’s Desk

Bill Hendershot’s office was above a dry cleaner on Main Street in the town where I grew up. The stairs creaked. His secretary Marge had been his secretary since I was in middle school, and she hugged me at the door and told me my mother had loved me very much, and I nearly lost it right there in the waiting room.

Bill was seventy-four. He wore a bow tie. He had a file on his desk with my mother’s name on it and a sealed manila envelope on top of the file.

“Your mother came in on October 8th,” he said. “By herself. She drove.”

I hadn’t known that.

“She sat where you’re sitting and she updated her will and she gave me this envelope and she told me not to open it. She said if anyone accused you of stealing from her after she was gone, I should open it in your presence and read it out loud.”

I put my hands flat on my knees to hold them still.

“She said if nobody accused you, I should burn it.”

Bill picked up the envelope. He looked at me over his glasses.

“Ready?”

“Yes.”

He slit it open with a letter opener and unfolded three pages of my mother’s handwriting.

I want to say I stayed composed. I didn’t.

She’d written it the way she talked. Rambling in the middle, sharp at the beginning and end. She named the withdrawals. Every one of them. The dates, the amounts, and why. Two thousand in May because I’d told her about our leaking roof and she wanted me to fix it. Fifteen hundred in June for Mark’s birthday because she wanted me to take him somewhere nice while I still had a husband who wasn’t burnt out from watching me grieve. A thousand in July for nothing, just because she wanted me to have it.

She wrote about Danielle. She wrote, and this is the part Bill read out loud in the same steady voice he’d used to read the rest:

“Danielle has been going through my checking account since I got sick. Kyle gave her access and I didn’t know until March, when she asked me at Easter about a charge at Kohl’s I didn’t recognize. She wasn’t asking to help. She was asking to check. I took her off the account the next week and I have not told Kyle why. If she accuses Jenny of anything after I’m gone, understand that this is a woman who was auditing a dying woman’s grocery spending. Jenny has never taken a dollar from me that I didn’t hand her, and most of what I tried to hand her she refused. Please give her the rest of what’s in the account after I’m gone, and please tell her I saw her.”

Bill lowered the pages.

“There’s more,” he said. “About the will.”

I nodded because I couldn’t speak.

“Your mother changed the distribution in October. It was previously a fifty-fifty split between you and Kyle. She changed it to seventy-thirty. Seventy to you. She left a written explanation, which is legally binding as an attachment. She cited caregiver contribution and specifically named Danielle’s, and I’m quoting, ‘ongoing surveillance and hostility’ as a factor.”

I let out a sound that wasn’t a laugh but wasn’t a sob either.

“Danielle’s petition to freeze the estate is going to fail,” Bill said. “Loudly. I’ll file the response tomorrow. Your mother’s letter, plus the bank footage, plus the medical records showing she was competent when she made these changes. It’s not a close case.”

“Bill,” I said. “How much of this can I share.”

He put his fingertips together.

“The will is a matter of public record once it’s filed for probate. That happens Monday. Anyone who wants to look it up can. Your mother’s letter about Danielle is not confidential. She wrote it specifically to be read out loud.”

“And the bank footage.”

“That’s yours. You can do what you want with it.”

I drove home and I did not call Kyle.

I did one thing.

I texted Aunt Louise.

I said, “I know Danielle told everyone I stole from Mom. I have proof I didn’t, and I have some things Mom wrote that I think you should see. Can I come by Saturday.”

She read it. I watched the little bubbles start and stop three times.

Then she wrote back: “Come at two. Bring everything.”

Aunt Louise’s living room on Saturday afternoon had six people in it. Louise. Rachel. Uncle Pete. Mom’s two church friends, Sharon and Dee. And Kyle’s boss Frank, Mom’s neighbor of twenty years, who Louise had called because she said if Frank believed me, Kyle’s whole social circle would believe me by Monday, and Louise apparently had opinions about how this was going to shake out.

I brought my laptop and a folder.

I did not perform. I did not cry, though I wanted to. I put the laptop on Louise’s coffee table and I played them the November footage first. My mother, thin and laughing, pointing at the teller’s screen.

Then I played May. And June. And July.

Then I read them Mom’s letter. All three pages. In her voice, as best I could remember it.

When I got to the part about Danielle auditing a dying woman’s grocery spending, Sharon put her hand over her mouth.

When I got to the part about Mom saying “I saw her,” Rachel started crying.

Frank was the one who spoke first.

“Jenny,” he said. “I owe you an apology. I stood in that parking lot and I didn’t say anything. I should have said something.”

“You didn’t know,” I said.

“I knew your mother,” he said. “That was enough. I should have known.”

Uncle Pete asked if he could have a copy of the letter. I’d printed six. I gave one to everyone in the room.

Louise walked me to my car. She held on to my arm at the curb like she was afraid I’d float off.

“Kyle,” she said. “You haven’t talked to Kyle.”

“No.”

“He’s going to hear all of this by tomorrow night.”

“I know.”

She looked at me for a long moment.

“You’re not going to call him first.”

“No.”

“Good,” she said. “Let him come to you.”

He came to me Wednesday.

—